So, here is my list of toys that aren't supposed to be scary, but totally are:
I don't know about you, but I just don't trust this horse!
NutcrackerNothing says "Christmas" like a creepy nutcracker staring you down!
Jack-In-The-BoxSeriously, who came up with this idea for a children's toy?
Ventriloquist DummyThere is nothing entertaining to me about a ventriloquist or his dummy!
ClownsI'm not sure if people were scared of clowns before Stephen King's IT came along, but I've always thought they were creepy!
DollsNot all dolls are scary I suppose, but the older they are, the scarier they are!
Are there any other scary toys that you can think of?